Fatcow Icon
Murdered girl’s mom asks ‘why?’
by Mallory Brown
Richmond County Daily Journal
Oct 06, 2012 | 46978 views | 47 47 comments | 50 50 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Reba Lynn Marie Ryan
Reba Lynn Marie Ryan
slideshow

Monica Eddins of Ellerbe said she is full of questions about the death of her 4-year-old daughter.

According to the Richmond County Sheriff’s Office, Reba Lynn Marie Ryan was found dead last Friday at her residence in Ellerbe, and authorities have charged 39-year-old Julius Juan Lilly with first degree murder and felony child abuse with serious bodily injury.

Sheriff James Clemmons Jr. confirmed earlier this week that Lilly was a “live-in boyfriend” of Eddins.

A week after the incident, the mother is still full of questions, as she recalls the special attributes of her little girl.

“(Reba) loved being outside and loved animals,” Eddins said on Friday. “She didn’t ever meet a stranger. She was very active and everything — she was very smart.”

Eddins added that her daughter also enjoyed playing “spoons,” an activity her grandfather taught her to do.

“Her grandpa had her playing spoons since she was old enough to hold them,” she said. “(Reba) loved her country music. She loved to sing — she had a beautiful voice. She said when she got older that’s what she wanted to do, she wanted to sing.”

Eddins said she is still struggling to comprehend the news she received last Friday.

“I was at work,” she said. “Everybody was asleep, and I got a phone call from (Lilly) at 7:35 a.m. I couldn’t answer my cell phone, so he called the store phone … ,”

Eddins, a manager at a gas station and convenience store in Ellerbe, said Lilly was looking for an acquaintance of theirs, a woman who was dating his cousin. The woman was also an assistant manager at the store, but was not there.

“I asked if everything was OK,” Eddins said. “I asked if Reba was still asleep and he said yes. Nothing sounded like anything was wrong, so I said ‘OK, I love you,’ and we said goodbye.”

A short time later, Eddins said she received a phone call from the same number — this time from her assistant manager, the woman Lilly had asked for earlier, who was now at Eddins’ residence.

“She was hysterical, crying and screaming,” Eddins said. “She was saying ‘you need to shut the store down and get over here — Reba’s not breathing.’

“When I got over there and asked (Lilly) what happened, he said he guessed he whooped (Reba) too hard. The paramedics were right behind me,” Eddins said.

According to the North Carolina Department of Correction, Lilly has been convicted of crimes in Stanly and Montgomery counties and spent time in state prison. Lilly’s record includes convictions of assault on a female, wanton injury to personal property, misdemeanor breaking and entering and communicating threats in Montgomery County.

When asked about her knowledge of Lilly’s criminal past, Eddins said she knew of only a couple of incidents.

“We’d talked about it,” she said. “I would even ask his family and friends, and they never told me about all the stuff I just found out about … I don’t know what happened (last Friday). I won’t know what happened until he tells me what happened because of me not being there. I’m completely confused.

“I feel like I was living with a stranger. I’d known him for over a year and had been living with him since December.”

Eddins said she and Lilly just had a son together, and that Lilly had never shown violent behavior before.

“I just don’t get it,” she said. “I’ve asked if I can talk to him face-to-face because I want answers. That way my heart could feel a little better. I could have some closure. What could my 4-year-old have done to a six-foot-four man to make him do what he has done? I want to know why.”

The heartbroken mother said that no matter what answer she receives, she knows it will not justify her loss.

“(Reba) had just learned how to write her name by herself, and how to tie her shoes by herself, because she was ready to start school,” Eddins said. “I can’t give up because I do have another child. Everybody expects me to be moping around because it hurts, it really hurts inside … but I have to keep going for my little boy. That’s the only reason I wake up every morning.”

Eddins said she has also tried to find comfort in the past few days.

“I’m trying to make peace with it,” she said. “Me and my preacher are talking. I know I was there for (Reba) every day, and that’s why I think my heart doesn’t hurt as bad … ,”

She elaborated on her feelings toward the accused killer.

“After what he took from me, I don’t wish death on him,” she said. “I don’t — because I want God to take him when it’s his time to go. And I want him to go before God and let God judge him. I don’t want to put the hurt on his family that he put on mine. I know he still has other kids. I want them to be able to see him. I don’t want to take him from them, because I know how bad this hurts.”

On Friday, Lilly remained incarcerated at the Richmond County Jail under no bond.

— Staff Writer Mallory Brown can be reached at 910-997-3111, ext. 18, or by email at mallorybrown@heartlandpublications.com



Comments
(47)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
|
October 31, 2012
Mother, how could you leave your child alone with a man you have known for less than a year, but yet moved him in last December? You couldnt have known him that long before he moved in. Secondly, just because you had a baby with a man doesn't guarantee that he is not a monster. Third, why in the hell he wasn't at work. Right there your judgement is suspect. Why would you date a man, let alone have a baby by him knowing he cant support you or your children. You are so dumb. You should be charged with negligence at least. You should never, I repeat never, leave your child alone with a man, let alone a female child!
|
October 10, 2012
I should start by saying I am beyond sorry for this loss, this future, this life, it is sad when anyone leaves this earth but when it is a child with so much potential so much life unlived...it is truly heartbreaking!! I have lost a child to a miscarriage and the pain and hurt is so much that i didnt think i would make it!!! I couldn't ever imagine losing a child again even to natural causes but knowing that someone willingly took the life of my child I would be MENTAL! There would not be a trial because i would have already took the life of the sorry piece of crap that took my child...and (mom) i get that you have to be strong for your other child but really your heart doesn't hurt?? Its not like she was battling cancer or a sickness or she had lived a long and healthy life she was a baby your heart should ache, you shouldn't even be able to function...what is wrong with you??? I have heard in the community that you feel "ganged up" on well where are you??? Defend yourself and the lost life of your child....no you are to busy defending a monster and probably trying to hide the one you are yourself!!! You should be charged with neglect endangerment...something.....i don't feel sorry for you....not at all...you are to blame just as much as him....it was his hands that took her but you poor judgment that initiated it!!! If you didn't want this beautiful baby someone would have...he dad for example....nope another little girl claiming to be a mother claiming to be a women your stupid ways and selfishness have TOOK YOUR DAUGHTER!!! So ask your self "my heart doesn't hurt i want to know why mom" was he worth it? ARE YOU HAPPY NOW??? JUSTICE FOR REBA!!!!!!!!
|
October 13, 2012
But as for the cowardly, the faithless, the detestable, as for murderers, the sexually immoral, sorcerers, idolaters, and all liars, their portion will be in the lake that burns with fire and sulfur, which is the second death -Revelation 21:8...

Everyone should be more focused on getting this evil man convicted, instead of focusing on damning this mother for the wrong that this man has done to her child. "He who is without sin cast the first stone"...tell me has anyone ever been nieve about the wrong someone has done to anyone of yalls children...If there has been anything bad that has happened to your children from evil men or anyone evil...is someone going to blame you...or if someone's child is a victim of sexual acts from evil people in the world...is someone going to blame you or better yet would you want someone to blame you if you were nieve about their past
|
October 13, 2012
Sloanlover: In case you are one of those who reads and interprets what you want, not what is actually there, you ask would you do this, would you do that if your 4 year old was just killed would your heart not hurt? Would you be okay with the monster who done it, not wish anything on him...i mean really get with it....if you are a parent it is your responsibility to know who you are leaving your child with it...a kidnapped child who is raped and murdered that i could not blame her for but she willingly left her kid with someone she barely knew...so yeah she is somewhat at fault...i mean you would leave your kids with a person you didn't know?? Find out they had a criminal past and be okay with it? Wow that doesn't sound like a caring parent to me....
|
October 29, 2012
My only comment is if u done lost a child.then u would know the feeling but until then only thing u can do is help this ladie be strong and try to live the rest of her life
|
October 10, 2012
It is telling that this mother is not even being truthful about her true legal name. So many questions circling: What is the time frame of how long was the mother gone to work and the death of this baby? Why was it so important for her to make sure the public knew she ended the phone to that childmurder with "I love you". Why is the newspaper not reporting on the tragedy here of a murdered baby and instead talking to the mother who is showing herself in a questionable light!
|
October 10, 2012
Evidently, my comparison of the person who killed my son and my feelings towards that person, against this so called mother, could not be posted. My original comment "did not have approval". I will always hate the person that killed my son and want him dead. You newspaper people can keep from posting my comment, but it still don't change the fact of how I feel now and will feel as long as I live. This so called mother, should feel like I feel, towards the killer of her daughter. ya'll suck.
|
October 09, 2012
To reba's dad,you stated that Reba told you, "Juan hurt me", "Daddy, I'm scared of Juan". So my question is Why didn't you get her out of that house? Why didn't you demand to have visitation, she was your child, you had rights. Months go by and your lil girl that told you this man hurt her and she was scared of him, she was left at the mercy of this abuser. Was CPS ever called to report what Reba told you. Reba was let down by so many people and eventually paid for it with her life. You don't have to answer these questions, you're not on trial here. I'm just wondering why you would come forward in a public forum and tell your story when you are one of the many people that (based on your own comments) could have saved her. How many reports were made to CPS, how many orders were filed with family court so that you could see your daughter? It's a shame that this beautiful baby girl had to endure so much pain in her short life. She is safe now in God's arms, she isn't abused anymore, she is at peace. JUSTICE FOR REBBA!!! :(
|
October 10, 2012
CPS had been called many times on the mother and the living condictions. He(the father) was in the process of taking the child from the mother. Questions had been asked many times over. The mother is one of the many that knows how to work the system. the fater's family members also had reported her several times but it always come back to everything was alright they didnt find anything. Just look at the system anyway. How many complaints go unread or even pushed to the side for months on end. There was no custody agreement. the mother brought the law with her to get the child from the father in June. I hope that I have answered your questions. Reba's Grandmother....RIP my little angel
|
October 10, 2012
Reports were made. Our system is seriously flawed. CPS workers tend to be VERY bad judges of character. Your statements are hurtful. The father very much loves his daughter and spoke out BEFORE this escalated to Reba's death. When a couple is going through a split, the system tends to lean in the favor of the custodial parent and sees the non-custodial parent as a trouble maker. CPS should be brought in to face some sort of neglect charges in this case.

Reba's father is hurting enough and no one on the outside looking in knows how much he wanted his little girl to be safe. He was simply trying to follow the rules and make sure he did it right. Unfortunately, it is Reba's mother and they system that failed Reba.
|
October 10, 2012
One of the most important things that I left out of my comment was, I am truly sorry for your loss. I am sorry that your family has to endure the grief from losing a child. However, most of all I am sorry for Reba; sorry for the pain she suffered. Only time will tell how many people will be charged and what those charges will be. I think this whole case should be turned over to State prosecutor or someone to assist RCS Office and RC detectives with the investigation. And if DSS and CPS were called; then that needs to be investigated as well. Alot of hands could have saved this baby and now all those hands are pointing fingers. I hope God will give yur family peace and help you recover from your loss.
|
October 11, 2012
freedomuchoose, two people have already told you that reports were filed and also stated that numerous attempts were made to help my daughter out of that mess. My family and friends try to do things the right way. So that it cannot be questioned later on. The "ones pointing fingers" are the same that tried to stop my childs death before it happened.
|
October 11, 2012
However, I do respect you voicing your opinion. I do agree that everything you have said. Things move slowly, too slowly, around here with DSS and CPS. They tend to investigate "supposed" cases of child abuse and neglect before "proven" cases. your child slips outside and twists their ankle and you will see DSS or CPS in a day or two. However, call and tell them a child has bruises on her legs, behind, and back and they get to it when they have time.
|
October 15, 2012
For future references for anyone reading. If custody has not been given to neither parent, legally no parent has a right. Either parent can keep the child up to six months or until court date.

|
October 09, 2012
No mother in her right mind would EVER make the comments this cold hearted b@ has made toward her own daughter. Sounds to me like she's prepping the public for her upcoming visit to see the dirtbag that did this. Her excuse is- she has a lot of questions??? Her only question should be is why did SHE not protect her child? I'm pretty sure it wasn't the first time he put his hands on that poor child and pretty sure she had knowledge of that. Soooo sad!!! Especially that NOONE was there to protect her! How could you not want the worst for someone that KILLED your child! Not accidentally- but brutality. I've heard of people forgiving people years later for things but come on not even a month later. Just get it over with and go marry him behind bars you stupid heartless b@$!*! But MOST Important RIP to that innocent beautiful baby.
|
October 09, 2012
First of all I want to say I am sorry to all the family Members and my prayers are with you all but the MOTHER I want to say you are a heartless no for good one woman I dont see how in the world any parent can be taking it this well all this show is you love this murderer more then your own child and my question is if you didnt want her why didnt you give her to her father and you say you dont want nothing bad to happen to him because he has other kids do honestly think after this the mother of the kids want him around their Kids ??? truly you use Very Bad judgement and you yourself deserves to be behind bars under the jail without food water and beat just as he beat your child I dont feel sorry for you one bit . I dont know what in th world gotten in you women that puts a man before her child yall are sick helpless and heartless selfish you put SEx first him second and your children where even when ever . My spet daughter lost her baby to sids and she would do almost anything to bring him back and one thing she wouldnt do is let a man kill her there are alot of mothers who would love to bring their kids back why you sit their and let a man kill yours cause you let him come into you home >>>>JUSTICE REBA
|
October 08, 2012
This story makes me sick! Her heart doesn't hurt?? What the heck? Really! I mean Lil Reba was not even my child and when I found out about the death of this child my heart broke and I started crying! Sounds to me like there is alot of investigating that needs to be done, not only with the Lilly, but with the mother and the other woman! It just doesn't make since to me! There is nothing that a child could do to make someone want to kill them, beat them to death! It disgust me! My thoughts about the situation, is that Lilly and the other woman were having an affair and Lil Reba walked in on them doing the nasty and Lilly flipped out and took it out on Lil Reba so she wouldn't tell her mama, who really doesn't give a crap about her daughter anyway! Anyway, just wish I could be the judge because there would be no life in prison, I would bring back being stoned to death! JUSTICE FOR REBA!!
|
October 08, 2012
I am just disgusted with this. It's pretty evident that she still loves her daughters killer. She would probably ask him to move back in if she could. She doesn't wish death on him? Are you kidding me?!! He sure didn't feel that way when he was hurting Reba. A week after your child's death and you have the audacity to say, "that’s why I think my heart doesn’t hurt as bad". Oh dear lord! Reba didn't stand a chance with her idiot mother her abusive boyfriend. I have no compassion what-so-ever for this woman. Someone needs to pay close attention here because she still has a newborn baby. She didn't do a thing to protect Reba. ~JUSTICE FOR REBA!!~
|
October 08, 2012
My heart truly goes out to the father and his family! My heart aches for you all, and I know that justice will prevail! I am praying for you all, and I hope they take a really good look at the mother!!! I mean...really??? You aren't so upset??? She isn't my child, and my heart is torn out over this. There hasn't a day gone by, since hearing of this, that that lil girl wasn't in my thoughts and prayers!!! The thought of a mother saying such as what she has said in this article makes me sick to my stomach!!! I'm not God...and I shouldn't judge the mother...but she was a piss poor mother in my eyes, and to many others as well!!! To A.J. and your family...stand firm, and demand answers...you all have plenty of people backing you...and I know that God will bring forth blessings that will bring the justice that lil Reba and all that love her deserves!!! JUSTICE FOR LIL REBA!!!
|
October 07, 2012
This four year old belomged to all of us and we need to demand justice, can you imagine the fear and horror she felt? This mother should be jailed also, she made the bad judgement call just to satisfy her hormones, and in the process put her baby alone with an animal who should never have been there. Everyone who reads this story knows the problem but because of policically correct laws cannot say it, but be assured of one thing, we have a good sheriff in Mr. Clemmons and he will see that this killer gets his just rewards, thank you Sheriff Clemmons, for all of us..

louis b long et al.
|
October 07, 2012
I have to agree with most of these ppl leaving comments on here. Y would anybody willingly leave their child with a know abuser. It doesn't even make sense. But then again i think the mother never had that to begin with. It is such h a tragedy that this had to happen. Makes ppl wonder y she never answered phone calls or texts back to ppl that wanted to see Reba. Makes ppl think she was covering up things if u ask me
|
October 07, 2012
How the **** does a mothers heart not hurt "as bad" when a man beats their child to death? How do you not wish death on a man who beats your 4 year old to death? How can You want this killer to be able to see his other kids? I think there's a lot here that needs to be questioned.... the mama. If he beat Reba to death, this was not the first time he's put his hands on that child!!! Saying no more, but we need JUSTICE FOR REBA!
|
October 06, 2012
Yes. My user name does ring true. I am Reba's father. These "statements" from my daughter's mother are complete b.s. I told the mother countless times that Reba told me, "Daddy, Juan hurt me." "Daddy, I'm scared of Juan." She always told me he would never hurt her...

I don't believe for a minute that she didn't know what was going on. She kept my daughter from me for three and a half months. The first time I saw my daughter since June was in the morgue Friday morning. Her heart doesn't hurt? Wow!

Tuesday night was my daughters viewing. While my family is all but in a state of shock she laughs and jokes with her friends and family about what she did earlier. I had no say-so what so ever in my daughters funeral arrangements or anything. My family had to call the funeral home to find out times and dates.

My baby did love to sing. She always loved to sing Drink In My Hand by Eric Church with me. I will always wonder what my little punk would've been and will always miss her. And I will never forgive those at fault...
|
October 07, 2012
Couldn't agree with u more. We r all behind u. Together we will make sure everybody that was involved will b brought to justice.
|
October 07, 2012
AJ My Thoughts and prayers are with you during this tragic time. I hope that you can find comfort in the fact nothing can ever harm you little one again. And I hope you can find the strength to forever seek justice for her, not only against the p.o.s. that took her but also against any living breathing soul that knew, thought, assumed, or believed that he had hurt her in any way before this and chose not to do anything to stop it from happening again! Be strong, keep your faith and know that God is good!
|
October 08, 2012
AJ, we all hope your precious daughter gets the justice she deserves. Praying for you and your family.
|
October 06, 2012
The murder of this child is such a tragedy. A tradgedy that could have been avoided. First of all the fact that this mother participated in this interview shows how ignorant she is; an interview that I hope will be used against her in court. Hopefully it will assist in her conviction because she needs to be charged also. She belongs in the cell right next to the animal that she allowed to murder her child. Not only is she showing us all how stupid she is; she is giving evidence that will hopefully be used against her in a criminal trial. She knew this man had a criminal record, had served time in prison, and had assault charges. She said she had known him a little over a year BUT she said she had been living with him since December, which means she let him live with her and her baby girl soon after meeting him. Reba is the face of innocence that parents should love and protect from harm and from evil. What you shouldn't do is selfishly put your child in harm's way so that you can invite an excon into your home, sleep with him, have a child with him and leave your daughter at his mercy. Nothing can bring Reba back' that's something Monica Eddins will live with the rest of HER life. I hope Social Services takes her son away from her, she shouldn't be allowed to have children. How could this woman say "I know I was there for Reba everyday, that's why my heart doesn't hurt as bad" Really? Your heart should hurt a million times worse, if you would have been there Reba would be here now. If you wouldn't have brought that criminal into your home, Reba would still be here. If you were not a selfish *^&% shacked up with a child killer, Reba would still be here. I don't know how you can look at yourself in the mirror. How many babies have to die before women such as Monica Eddins have respect for themselves, protect their children from evil and stop setting up house with men they hardly know. Monica, you say you want to go see him face to face, I hope they lock your a$$ up when you get there.
|
October 07, 2012
AMEN!!!!!
|
October 08, 2012
I second that AMEN !
|
October 06, 2012
This story does not make sense. I hope the police look at this case because it's a lot like the Shaniya Davis murder case that was in Fayetteville. I wouldn't care what answers a mother can get it don't erase the pain of losing a child so there is so much more to this case that needs to be looked at.I bet if Social Service takes the son away she will begin to talk. NO mother leaves her daughter with a boyfriend that she has only been dating for a year! JUSTICE FOR REBA!!!!
|
October 06, 2012
I'm glad your heart doesn't hurt as bad. Your daughter didn't do ANYTHING to make a 6 foot 4 violent man "whoop" her to the point of death. A child that small really shouldn't be getting spanked. A child that young definitely shouldn't be getting hit with a belt or other object and this corporal punishment certainly shouldn't be delivered by her mother's "live in boyfriend." You owed it to your daughter to know everything about a man you brought into her home and you fell short. The Daily Journal should be ashamed for running this interview. Personally I think you're as responsible as Lilly is for this horrible and avoidable tragedy. I'm glad your heart doesn't hurt as bad; I wish I could say the same for all the people especially the mothers who have read about what happened to your precious little baby girl.
|
October 08, 2012
VERY well said ! She was the one person who could have protected her child and she didn't !
|
October 06, 2012
This is her grandmother and like I cmmented last week my son nor his family has been allowed to see Reba for the last several months. She wouldn't answer phone calls or text messages from us. There is reasons why she (Reba) had been kept from us. My son loves his daughter and is wanting answers also but not just from the man that took his daughter life but the woman that let it happen. When your a parent and you have small children you check into the past of people you are planning on leaving your child with. I have so much more to say but and so very angry right now. Our hearts are all breaking. We want: JUSTICE FOR REBA. Grandma loves you and your memories will always be right
|
October 06, 2012
Agreed ! 100% !!! Where was she when her child was being beaten to death ? She has a lot to answer for ! It is highly unlikely that this was a one time incident.

*Justice for Reba*
|
October 06, 2012
Bless you and your son and the rest of your family. I can't imagine the pain you're feeling, especially since this was so obviously avoidable. You all must have so many questions and suspicions especially considering how you didn't get to see your granddaughter in the months leading up to this heart breaking event. I hope you are all given the justice your family and your granddaughter deserves and I hope that somehow you are all able to find some sort of comfort and peace in the midst of all this. As the mother of a little girl not too much younger than little Reba my heart aches for you and your son.
|
October 07, 2012
I'm a aunt to the grandmother and great aunt to Reba's father. I keep this precious little girl and what happen to her on my mind nearly all the time. I want that 6' 4" man to suffer not live the life of leisure in jail or prison, let him know that his life is being taken away for what he done to this small innocent child. If he could get out of jail this stupid woman that was suppose to be a mother and protect her child from harm would welcome him right back into her life and bed. If someone harmed one of my sons today and they are 42 and 39 yrs. old, I would be full of anger and bitternes at who had harmed them. I would have been ashamed to give a interview to a newspaper to be read by the public and the newspaper sgould have got there interview from someone who was truly hurting from the death of this child. The funeral home she picked done nothing for the father and his family, even lined him up for funeral procession at the back of line. Yet they expect half the funeral expenses. Sorry for this long and rambling write up.
|
October 08, 2012
You all are in my thoughts and prayers. The loss of this sweet child is a senseless tragedy. It amazes me how many women move men in with their children that they know nothing about. A mother's job is to put her children first not her love life! I hope justice is served!!
|
October 08, 2012
I just want you all to know that I am praying for you all, and my heart is aching for you all. You all have a huge community of people that is backing you up and want justice for lil Reba. While I know your hearts will always be broken over this tragedy...I hope you take a lil comfort in knowing that we all are with you and behind you all 100%!!! God bless you all!!!
|
October 06, 2012
I agree that it seems that there is more to this story. Seems like she is holding back and in a weird way protecting this beast. Sounds like the words of a battered woman to me.....like she is afraid to say what she is really feeling out of fear from him still. It is none of my business the details of this story but I do pray for the mother and for the loss of life of this precious little girl. I pray that someone close to her can help her put back the broken pieces as best as she can and stay away from this monster and not stand by him as he faces the charges against him. That is the only justice for the loss of this beautiful child of God.
|
October 06, 2012
Battered woman, my fanny ! She is not battered. She was a willing participant in her daughter's death. She sat back and did nothing, at the very least. At most, she may have mistreated the child herself !
|
October 08, 2012
In my opinion she is hiding something...if she was battered...she wouldn't want to see or speak to the man who hurt this beautiful child of God. She DON'T deserve to be called a mother!!! I hope and pray they take a look at the details behind all this. She knows more than she is admitting to...and in my opinion they won't be COMPLETE justice for lil Reba until she is made to tell what she knows!!! *JUSTICE 4 LIL REBA*
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

Gas Prices
Sponsored By:

Featured Businesses
Recipes
Sponsored By: